Homepage Feature

Recycling graves in Germany

Play
Download

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Germany is a world leader in recycling garbage, and Germans are proud of it. But it’s also the only country in Europe that recycles its graves, too. Germans have mixed feelings about that custom. Daniel Estrin reports from Berlin. (Photo: Daniel Estrin) Download MP3

Read the Transcript
This text below is a phonetic transcript of a radio story broadcast by PRI’s THE WORLD. It has been created on deadline by a contractor for PRI. The transcript is included here to facilitate internet searches for audio content. Please report any transcribing errors to theworld@pri.org. This transcript may not be in its final form, and it may be updated. Please be aware that the authoritative record of material distributed by PRI’s THE WORLD is the program audio.

JEB SHARP: I’m Jeb Sharp and this is The World. Germany is a world leader in recycling garbage, and Germans are pretty proud of that. It’s also the only country in Europe that recycles its graves, too. Some Germans have mixed feelings about that custom. Daniel Estrin reports from Berlin.

DANIEL ESTRIN:  Last spring, Jessica Jacoby went to visit her grandmother’s grave.

JESSICA JACOBY:  And there was a sticker. This yellow sticker. “Family members, please contact.” When you see the sticker, you know they are about to demolish the grave.

ESTRIN: This has been the practice in Germany for centuries. You don’t own your own plot, you rent it. In Berlin, the rental period is 20 years. When the twenty years runs out, the cemetery asks the family members to pay the rent for the next 20. Rent can cost between $900 and $5000.

JACOBY: And if you don’t cough up, or rather, your children or grandchildren or whoever, the stone is removed and other people are put in your grave.

ESTRIN: Walking around the cemetery, we saw a few other yellow notices announcing nearly-expired graves.

JACOBY: The other sticker is even more rude. It says, [GERMAN SPEAKING] Mean, quite literally, means time to rest in peace has run out. Which is, by so many people, just taken for granted and they just shrug their shoulders, say well, that’s just the way of the world. It’s not the way of the world. But it’s the way of Germany.

OLAF IHLEFELDT: Recycling the old graves, it’s, in Germany, absolutely normal.

ESTRIN:  Olaf Ihlefeldt directs the main cemetery serving southwest Berlin. He says once they see the notices, most families pay for twenty or forty years. After that, most of them let the graves go. And then there are those families who never get the memo. They come to visit their loved one’s grave and find someone else buried there instead.

IHLEFELDT: It’s a big problem. They come there, and they see an empty grave. Without stone, without plants, this green field. This is hard sometimes for the family.

ESTRIN: Ihlefeldt sends just one letter. No phone calls. If he doesn’t hear from the family, he removes the tombstone. The old bones stay in the ground and the plot is ready for a new body. German cemeteries began reusing graves 200 years ago to save space. But most Germans today opt for cremation, which frees up cemetery space. So he says Germany doesn’t really need to rent plots and recycle graves. But it brings in good money.

IHLEFELDT: We could let it be. We could let the place there forever. We have enough space at the cemetery. But the other part is we haven’t the money. The cemetery is not rich.

ESTRIN: So what do Germans think about graveyard recycling? Ihlefeldt says the younger generation is more open to it. Ludmila Wolf, a 24-year-old student, says when her parents die, she won’t mind giving up their graves.

LUDMILA WOLF: I don’t need this place to go to think of them or to talk to them. I don’t need to go to their bones to be near them, which I’m not because they’re dead.

ESTRIN: But Stephan Marks, a social scientist, says his parents’ graves have been replaced with new tombstones and new bodies and he’s not very happy about it.

STEPHAN MARKS: I think it’s strange. It’s not respectful. It doesn’t show respect for our past, for our ancestors.

ESTRIN:  There are some exceptions to the rule. Muslim and Jewish cemeteries are exempted for religious reasons. And the graves of famous Germans are kept untouched for posterity. That’s one reason why Jessica Jacoby is so upset. Her grandmother, Hilde Korber, was famous too. She was a German actress in the 1930s who founded an acting school, and helped Jews escape Nazi Germany. For decades, the city paid to keep up her grave. But every year the city trims its list of VIP graves, and last year, Korber didn’t make the cut. A city council representative told me by email that’s because the public no longer remembers who she was. Her granddaughter doesn’t agree with that way of thinking.

JACOBY: The preservation of memory in this country is skin deep. It is not seen as something all-encompassing. But it’s a very limited and limiting concept of memory. Who’s important, who’s not important.

ESTRIN: Jacoby’s family is now paying the rent, so her grandmother can continue to rest in peace. But Jacoby herself isn’t at peace because she worries about her own grave.

JACOBY: I don’t have children. And when I am gone, who will take care? No one will.

ESTRIN: For the World, I’m Daniel Estrin, Berlin.


Copyright ©2009 PRI’s THE WORLD. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to PRI’s THE WORLD. This transcript may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without prior written permission. For further information, please email The World’s Permissions Coordinator at theworld@pri.org.

Discussion

4 comments for “Recycling graves in Germany”

  • dan

    Very illuminating. Germans only look like civilized people, but there is something wrong with them.

  • Stephanie

    Germany is certainly not the only country in Europe recycling graves. Belgium has been doing it for decades Plots are not for sale, only for lease, maximum thirty years. And there are plenty of other countries and municipalities with leased plots where there is a turnover in bodies. Check your facts before making sweeping pronouncements, Mr. Estrin.

  • Claudia Perez-Maldonado

    Grave rental is a very common practice in Mexico City where I am from. There you rent a grave for 7 years and you can renew the rental agreement 2 more times, after 21 years your death relative is taken out. You decide what you want to do with the remains. Some people cremate them while other people leave the Cemetery managers to deal with them. I have seen bones lying around and old coffins on the side roads inside of the cemetery which are pretty disturbing scenes. Grave rental is very common, especially in public cemeteries (Panteon Civil, Panteon de San Lorenzo, etc), however I am not sure that it also happens all over the country. Mexico City is so densely populated that cemeteries cannot keep up with the amount of plots required, and cannot afford selling a plot to a single family when it can be used for many families over the years.

  • jeffersonia

    Not sure where your information that Germany is the only country in Europe to do this comes from.  A quick net search shows that it’s also done in Spain, and appears to be mandatory in Greece, unless one can afford a permanent plot which costs some 150,000 Euros.