Homepage Feature

Murders prompt new construction in West Bank

Play
Download

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Download MP3

The funeral for five members of the Fogel family took place on Sunday at a Jerusalem cemetary. Israeli media estimated 20,000 people attended.


By Matthew Bell

Israeli security forces are searching for the perpetrators of a vicious attack over the weekend. It happened in a West Bank settlement outside of Nablus called Itamar.

As they slept in their beds Friday night, Udi and Ruth Fogel and three of their children – including their three-month-old infant – were stabbed to death. Israeli officials said Palestinian terrorists are the prime suspects.

The funeral for the Fogel couple and their three children was held on Sunday at a Jerusalem cemetery. An estimated 20-thousand Israelis came to mourn the loss of Udi and Ruth, 10 year-old Yoav, four year-old Elad and the baby, Hadas. Their bodies were wrapped in Jewish prayer shawls and laid out in a row.

One of the speakers was Yisrael Meir Lau, chief rabbi of Tel Aviv and a Holocaust survivor. In comments just before the ceremony began, Lau might have captured the sentiment of many Israelis, when he said such an attack makes it difficult to imagine this long, vicious cycle of violence ever coming to an end.

“If you have to deal with such people that the word ‘human beings’ doesn’t fit them. They behave like animals, like beasts,” he said. “I’m a survivor, as a child. And I thought that in the moment the Jewish independent state was declared 63 years ago, came an end to all this suffering, this misery, this bloodshed. Unfortunately, we still have to fight for our very existence.”

Samaria

A long-time friend of the Fogel family, Moshe Asher, said these murders would only strengthen the Jewish connection to Samaria, the Biblical name for parts of the West Bank.

“Samaria is the land of our forefathers,” Asher said. “And events like this usually lead to us putting down more roots and building more settlements there.”

And in fact, over the weekend, the Israeli government approved plans for 400 new Jewish homes in the West Bank. Settlement supporters said that’s a start, but they want more. Israel’s interior minister said there should be 1,000 new homes for every Israeli killed there.

The Palestinian Authority reacted to recent events by condemning the announcement on new settlement building, and also condemning Friday night’s murders.

Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas gave an interview to Israel Radio this morning. He said the killings were despicable, immoral and inhuman. He said, “Scenes like these – the murder of infants and children and a woman slaughtered – cause any person endowed with humanity to hurt and to cry.”

Incitement index

Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu welcomed that statement from Abbas. But many Israelis believe Palestinian expressions of remorse to be hollow: Israeli officials said official Palestinian incitement against Israel and Jews is to blame for the cycle of violence in this conflict.

They just created what’s being called an “incitement index,” that’s been sent out to the media. Israeli government spokesman Mark Regev said president Abbas should not be satisfied with his latest condemnation of the attack.

“(He needs) to stop institutional incitement to violence and hatred that unfortunately is still prevalent in Palestinian official media, controlled by the Palestinian government, and in their school system,” Regev said. “Ultimately, it’s very important that he creates there a culture of peace instead of the all-too-existing culture of hate.”


The Palestinian president has just called for the creation of a new commission on incitement that would include US participation. Regev said the Israeli government is considering the offer.

But Palestinian spokesman Ghassan Khatib said Israel is guilty of incitement as well.

“The presence of the Israeli occupation on the Palestinian territories and the behavior of the Israeli occupation, including the behavior of the settlers, is the main cause of incitement for the Palestinians,” Khatib said.

Palestinians said Israeli settlers were behind a series of revenge attacks over the weekend, including incidents of vandalism and stone throwing. Yesterday, Palestinians reportedly threw stones at a bus of Israelis returning from the funeral in Jerusalem. The Israeli military has deployed additional forces in the West Bank and have detained about 20 Palestinians for questioning.

Discussion

8 comments for “Murders prompt new construction in West Bank”

  • Anonymous

    Have the courage to show the actions of the barbarians, the way they slaughtered that poor family. Show what and who Israel is really dealing with. Much easier to deal with political pronouncements and ignore showing the reality of what Israel is trying to protect herself from. These are the pictures released of the murders, with permission from the remaining family; they want the world to know: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/142846

    • Anonymous

      And, who are the barbarians? No one knows, do they?
      The Israelis who will not follow International conventions and rulings; and murder US sailors are certainly barbarians. Some Hamas maybe barbarians, but hard to term those throwing spitballs “barbarian”.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    Let’s stop pretending – from today’s Jerusalem Post.
    By ITAMAR MARCUS AND NAN JACQUES ZILBERDIK
    03/13/2011 22:57.

    Incitement is not just another issue to be negotiated over like borders, water and refugees; message of hate threatens peaceful solutions.

    The Palestinian Authority and its leaders share the blame for the murders of those five Israelis from Itamar on Friday – including two children and an infant – along with the terrorists who committed them. It is the PA and its leaders who have prepared the ground for these murders with the incessant incitement to hatred and the glorification of violence and terror.

    In spite of its conciliatory statements in English, the PA continues to use all the structures it controls to demonize Israelis and to promote violence. Terrorists are presented as heroes and role models for Palestinians, teaching that killing Israelis is a way to earn eternal fame.

    Just two months ago, PA President Mahmoud Abbas sent a clear message of support for terror when he awarded $2000 to the family of a terrorist who attacked IDF soldiers. Last week, the PA’s official daily Al-Hayat Al-Jadida announced a football tournament named after Wafa Idris, the first female Palestinian suicide bomber, and three weeks ago PA TV, which is under the direct control of Abbas’s office, broadcast videos glorifying the terrorist Habash Hanani, who in May 2002 entered Itamar and murdered three Israeli students. Twice the PA named summer camps after the terrorist Dalal Mughrabi, who in 1978 led the most deadly attack in Israel’s history in which 37 civilians were killed in a bus hijacking, both in 2008 and again this past summer.

    But the long arm of the PA’s promotion of violence and terror goes even farther, penetrating the realm of culture and music, which has been used so often in recent years in other places in the world to promote peace and tolerance. Last year, PA TV broadcast a number of performances of a band called Alashekeen, including a song anticipating the conquering of Israel through holy war. The song presents all of Israel as “Palestine,” mentioning the Carmel region near Haifa, and the cities of Lod, Ramle, and Jerusalem as regions to be liberated: “In Ramle we are grenades… the Palestinian revolution awaits [them]… We replaced bracelets with weapons. We attacked the despicable [Zionists]. This invading enemy is on the battlefield. This is the day of consolation of jihad. Pull the trigger. We shall redeem Jerusalem, Nablus and the country.”

    More significant than the repeated exposure on PA TV and at cultural events was the fact that Abbas chose to honor the musical group. He issued a presidential decree turning it into an official Palestinian national band.

    COMPOUNDING THE PA’s nationalistic hate promotion are its Islamic-based messages. The PA seems to have adopted what was once thought to be only Hamas ideology, that the conflict with Israel is a Ribat – a religious war for Allah to defend Islamic land in which conflict with Israel is uncompromising. Abbas’s appointed minister of religion, Mahmoud Habbash, has taught repeatedly that the conflict with Israel is not territorial but is in accordance with Islamic law: “Allah has preordained for us the Ribat on this blessed land. We are committed to it by Allah’s command. Let no one be mistaken or under the illusion that Ribat is a choice and nothing more. It is a commandment.”

    He has also preached that the conflict against Israel – over all of Israel – is cited in the Koran: “The catastrophe, in truth, did not begin in 1948, but began perhaps in 1917 with the cursed [Balfour] Declaration, which gave a promise to those who did not deserve it… Since that date, resolute people, fighters and Ribat fighters have not ceased upon our blessed land… This conflict is explicit in the Koran and our obligation with regard to it is clarified by the Koran.”

    In short, the PA, like the Hamas, is telling its people that Islam does not allow for reconciliation with Israel.

    WITH CONTINUOUS messages like this coming from the so-called moderate leadership of the PA, is it any wonder that people can go on terror rampages like the one in Itamar this weekend? Palestinians may assume that their leaders and society will honor them if they murder Israelis, that their families will receive payment if they are killed, and that their religion encourages Israel’s disappearance.

    Was the terrorist who committed those brutal killings dreaming about a future Palestinian summer camp in his name? Was he imagining Allah granting him everlasting rewards in paradise for fulfilling his command? Did he feel that he was fulfilling his national duty and would receive a financial reward? And what about the international community which has accepted and naively believed PA leaders’ assurances that incitement had stopped? It was the international community, represented by US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, which stipulated preconditions for the PA to enter into a renewed peace process: “We will only work with a Palestinian Authority government that unambiguously and explicitly accepts the Quartet’s principles: A commitment to non-violence, recognition of Israel, and acceptance of previous agreements and obligations, including the Road Map” (House Appropriations Subcommittee on State, April 23, 2009).

    The Road Map states that “all official Palestinian institutions end incitement against Israel.”

    The international community has completely failed because it never followed up to see if these preconditions had actually been met, but gladly satisfied itself with Abbas’s promises, and continues to fund the PA.

    Everyone involved in the peace process is making a tragic mistake by assuming the incitement is just another issue that has to be dealt with, like the issues of water, borders, and refugees. All of those are issues that must be negotiated as part of a peace process. But as long as the Palestinian Authority continues to teach these messages, clearly there is no peace process.

    It is incumbent on the international community to inform the Palestinian Authority that a condition for “working” with it, as Clinton stated, is that it erases the messages of hate and replaces them with peace promotion.

    And until that time the international community must ostracize and isolate the Palestinian Authority, just as they do Hamas, and stop pretending there is a peace process.

    Itamar Marcus is director of Palestinian Media Watch (www.palwatch.org). Nan Jacques Zilberdik is a senior analyst at Palestinian Media Watch.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    More on incitement: ironically, on the same day as the attack, the PA named a town square after Dalal Mugrabi:

    http://www.jta.org/news/article/2011/03/13/3086386/west-bank-square-dedicated-for-palestinian-terrorist
    West Bank square dedicated for Palestinian terrorist.

    March 13, 2011.

    JERUSALEM (JTA) — Palestinians in an official ceremony named a town square in the West Bank after a terrorist involved in killing 37 Israelis.

    Members of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah faction were on hand Sunday for the unveiling of a plaque in memory of Dalal Mughrabi in Al-Bireh, near Ramallah, Reuters reported. No PA government officials attended the ceremony, according to Reuters.

    Mughrabi was killed in a 1978 bus hijacking on Israel’s coastal road. She had directed the hijacking of two buses on the coastal road between Haifa and Tel Aviv, which led to the murder of 37 Israelis, including 13 children.

    One year ago, the Palestinian Authority had canceled official ceremonies to name the town square for Mughrabi after pressure from U.S. peace envoy George Mitchell and Vice President Joe Biden at Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s request. The planned ceremony conflicted with a Biden visit to the region.

    The PA said at the time that it would place the official monument at a later date.

    • Anonymous

      Hmm, the PA listened and cooperated. Israel does not.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    More on incitement: ironically, on the same day as the attack, the PA named a town square after Dalal Mugrabi:

    http://www.jta.org/news/article/2011/03/13/3086386/west-bank-square-dedicated-for-palestinian-terrorist
    West Bank square dedicated for Palestinian terrorist.

    March 13, 2011.

    JERUSALEM (JTA) — Palestinians in an official ceremony named a town square in the West Bank after a terrorist involved in killing 37 Israelis.

    Members of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas’ Fatah faction were on hand Sunday for the unveiling of a plaque in memory of Dalal Mughrabi in Al-Bireh, near Ramallah, Reuters reported. No PA government officials attended the ceremony, according to Reuters.

    Mughrabi was killed in a 1978 bus hijacking on Israel’s coastal road. She had directed the hijacking of two buses on the coastal road between Haifa and Tel Aviv, which led to the murder of 37 Israelis, including 13 children.

    One year ago, the Palestinian Authority had canceled official ceremonies to name the town square for Mughrabi after pressure from U.S. peace envoy George Mitchell and Vice President Joe Biden at Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s request. The planned ceremony conflicted with a Biden visit to the region.

    The PA said at the time that it would place the official monument at a later date.

  • Anonymous

    Yisrael Meir Lau, chief rabbi of Tel Aviv, knows better. He neglects to mention that the Jewish independent state was declared 63 years ago, over the strong objections to the landowners, aka, Palestinians. How could he expect “an end to all this suffering, this misery, this bloodshed” when the indigenous population’s land and homes were being stolen or burned by the Jewish Irgun terrorist organization which killed many British police.and soldiers as well as massacring hundreds of Palestinians.

    Atrocities have been committed by both sides. That they were initiated by the would-be Israelis is of little comfort to any victim or family. But, now in ascendance, the Israelis get to re-write the History. Just as in the US, we successfully stole this land from the Indians or Mexico committing many more atrocities than the Indians ever did. This is just cowboys and Indians Middle Eastern style with both sides saying, “Unfortunately, we still have to fight for our very existence.”

    At this point there appears to be no evidence that these murders were committed by Palestinians of any stripe. The murder of only one family, including the children, by knife sounds more like a crime of Passion or serial murder – but could indicate a setup by Zealots – Israeli ultra-Nationalists or non-Palestinian Fundamentalists – to create an incendiary incident.

    The sooner Netanyahu is replaced as Prime Minister by some non-hardliner who will stand up to the ultra-religious Jews and justly compromise, the sooner Peace can come. Then, no one will have to fight for their very existence any longer.

  • Anonymous

    Incitement is not another issue to be negotiated over like borders, water and refugees; message of detest threatens calm solutions.

    Motorcycle Accessories