Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell is a Jerusalem-based Middle East reporter. He has been with The World since 2001 and has filed stories from cities across the US and abroad.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

First Large-Scale Solar Field Could be a Model for Israel-Palestinian Partnership

The inauguration of Israel's first solar field, at a kibbutz in the Negev Desert, on June 5, 2011. (photo: Matthew Bell)

The inauguration of Israel's first solar field, at a kibbutz in the Negev Desert, on June 5, 2011. (photo: Matthew Bell)

As a small Middle Eastern country with no oil of its own, Israel’s long-held dream of energy independence has been just that, a dream. And as for the Palestinians, not having a state of their own has also put energy independence out of reach.

But one thing Israel and the Palestinian territories do have in abundance is sunshine. So, why not go solar?

Sunday, Israel unveiled its first commercial solar field at Kibbutz Ketura. The facility consists of a few dozen rows of 15 foot-high solar panels in the southern desert. When it goes online, the five mega-watt field will supply electricity to three nearby kibbutzim.

The Israeli company behind the project – Arava Power Company – says this is just the beginning. Executives say they are planning to sink $2 billion of investment capital into 40 more solar projects in Israel.

It is early days still for Israel’s commercial solar industry. But this one facility is already seen as a model for an interesting new partnership.

Gershon Baskin is an Israeli activist trying to help start alternative energy projects in the Palesitnian territories. (photo: Matthew Bell)

Gershon Baskin, an American-born Israeli activist and a senior advisor to Palestine Power, which is getting help from the multinational parent company of Arava Power.

Baskin says it is high time for Israelis and Palestinians to get serious about alternative energy.

“Israel has been the cutting edge in the development of green technologies, but most of it is exported,” Baskin said. “Israel is pretty backwards in terms of its own care of its own environment. And Palestine is even worse.”

Baskin added, that “for two peoples who are fighting over land that they claim that they love, they’ve done a tremendous job of polluting this place, of destroying the land, destroying the environment, destroying the water resources we have, polluting the air, you name it. This country is an environmental mess.”

Power Deficit

Beyond the aim of saving the environment, there are strategic reasons for Israelis and Palestinians to help each other go solar. Israelis, for example, are living with an electrical power deficit and the government plans to make up for it with coal.

At the same time, Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza buy almost all of their power from Israel. Gershon Baskin says every kilowatt hour produced by Palestinian solar power would end up helping Israel.

“We’ll save the environment in Israel,” Baskin said. “We’ll save the environment in Palestine by having renewable energy. It all goes together: it fits economically, it fits environmentally and it fits in terms of building models for peaceful coexistence.”

The politics of Israeli-Palestinian cooperation, of course, are problematic, to say the least. One example: Baskin’s Palestinian partner did not attend the ceremony this weekend at Kibbutz Ketura in southern Israel.

Hanna Siniora is former editor of an Arabic language daily newspaper. Now, he is working to bring alternative energy - like solar - to the Palestinian territories. (photo: Matthew Bell)

Hanna Siniora says the event fell on the same day that major Palestinian protests were planned to mark the anniversary of the 1967 war with Israel.

“I could not feel myself able to go and celebrate something which I support ­ renewable energy ­ during such a difficult period historically,” Siniora said from his office in Jerusalem. “Our people were actually trying to tell the Israeli public and Israeli government, enough of occupation, we want to be also free and independent like you.”

Siniora says building up the economic infrastructure of the Palestinian territories is equally as important as opposing the Israeli occupation. Electrical power is one part of that, he said. It’s pricey, but there¹s one big advantage to solar energy.

“Even if it is more expensive,” Siniora said. Israel “cannot prevent the rays of the sun.”

Siniora and Baskin said they are laying the groundwork to build solar fields in the West Bank. And that means finding investors, finding land to build on and navigating the Palestinian bureaucracy.

Then, there is the nagging issue of politics, again.

Nothing scares off investors like the unkown and right now, it’s very difficult to see a clear path ahead for bringing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict closer to a resolution.

Discussion

7 comments for “First Large-Scale Solar Field Could be a Model for Israel-Palestinian Partnership”

  • Anonymous

    It’s an excellent example of cooperation in clean energy….hopefully everybody we’ll be independent of fossile fuels soon. They are not only affecting our planet, but also putting money in the wrong pockets.

  • Anonymous

    It’s an excellent example of cooperation in clean energy….hopefully everybody we’ll be independent of fossile fuels soon. They are not only affecting our planet, but also putting money in the wrong pockets.

  • http://iranaware.blogspot.com/ Iran Aware

    Unfortunately Gaza has already proven themselves for not being able to handle free technology given to them without destroying it.I wouldn’t spend a dime to build anything for them,they will just wreck it first chance they get cause”someone did them wrong again.” make them use campfires for a few years before you give them anything,they have to earn it.A state is not given,it is EARNED. They dont get that.

  • http://www.facebook.com/nmajdalani Nada Majdalani

    I do not really knwo where to start from. Well generally the article reflects a bright example of cooperation between the two sides, and this is how some sources of media and organizations deem to bring the image that all is rosy and dandy. I still do not understand the fruit of this cooperation, when solar units are placed on an occupied land and serving settlments of occupiers (kibutz)! what kind of celebration of cooperation is this. this can be rather called collaboration! there are thousands of Palestinian communties deprived to their right to basic infrastructure services, one of which is electricity. Now if Mr. Saniora and Mr. Baskin blame it on lack of funds and Palestinian bureaucracy, I would like to remind them of why Palestinians have no access to adequate portions of land to establish such projects, and would like to remind also of the Israeli Civil Administration bureaucracy that controls over 60% of the West Bank land, and interfers and delays projects forcing donors to give up and pullout funds. Shame on cooperation when it denies basic rights of the occupied!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Cimber-Maurice-Moshe/618910343 Cimber Maurice-Moshe

    Through Nada Majdalani’s reaction, dear Gershon, you can guess how much you are “preaching in the desert” and that the road you would like Israeli’s and Palestinians to walk down together is still a huge distance away. She does express nothing else but  mainstream Palestinian views about the current situation and the near future. I have to concede that even someone as me that has regularly defended the same optimism as you did about a common future in front of my pessimistic entourage, starts feeling the cause is hopeless.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Cimber-Maurice-Moshe/618910343 Cimber Maurice-Moshe

    Through Nada Majdalani’s reaction, dear Gershon, you can guess how much you are “preaching in the desert” and that the road you would like Israeli’s and Palestinians to walk down together is still a huge distance away. She does express nothing else but  mainstream Palestinian views about the current situation and the near future. I have to concede that even someone as me that has regularly defended the same optimism as you did about a common future in front of my pessimistic entourage, starts feeling the cause is hopeless.  

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Glen-Pagelson/1769084719 Glen Pagelson

    Nada, the kibbutz is not on land occupied since 1967. It is in the Arava desert which has been part of Israel since its founding in 1948. If you don’t accept us, then of course we have nothing to talk about. But I suggest you look forward and not backward. I suggest you accept the existence of Israel and the potential of a peaceful Middle East where Palestinians and Jews can work together for our mutual benefit. That is my dream. I suggest you consider this vision.