Georgia Businesses Suffering from State Immigration Law

Migrant worker in Georgia (photo: Kristian Weatherspoon)

Migrant worker in Georgia (photo: Kristian Weatherspoon)

By Shomial Ahmad of station WABE in Atlanta

Parts of a tough new immigration law went into effect Friday in Georgia. It’s the latest instance of a US state seeking to make it harder for illegal immigrants to live and work within its borders.

Earlier this week, a federal judge blocked some of the law’s provisions. But other parts of the legislation are now being enforced, such as the one that makes it a felony to use false information when applying for a job.

The new law is already impacting Georgia industries that rely on undocumented workers.

(photo: Kristian Weatherspoon)

It’s the tail end of blackberry season in South Georgia. Isabel Rojas is out in the heat, with an American flag scarf covering her head. She’s bending and plucking through the blackberry vines. She’s trying to get plump, deep purple berries. She said there aren’t as many workers as there usually are.

Rojas said there used to be 75 workers here, but now there are only 40 and that some migrant workers who came from Florida left after just one day. They were scared, she said, of the new Georgia law.

But Rojas, who herself is undocumented, plans on staying in the state even with the new law.

“I got all my babies here, they grow up, they marry,” Rojas said. “I’ve got five grandbabies. Here is my life.”

Georgia Governor Nathan Deal signed House Bill 87 into law right when the blackberries were ready to be harvested. At the bill’s signing in mid-May, Deal said his aim was to deal with an issue being ignored by the federal government, and to help his state during tough economic times.

“With an illegal population that is estimated to be almost 500,000, the collective financial cost to our educational, health care, and correctional infrastructure is in the billions,” Deal said.

(photo: Kristian Weatherspoon)

But critics of the bill point out that undocumented workers help Georgia businesses bring in billions of dollars, and the new law is already hurting them. Take the state’s $69 billion agriculture industry. Bryan Tolar, president of Georgia Agribusiness Council, is opposed to the bill, and said it has hurt his industry in the past six weeks.

“So what we’ve seen is about a 30 percent loss in that labor force, so we’re looking at a 200 to $250 million loss potentially,” Tolar said.

Gary Paulk give me a tour of his blackberry farm where piles of berries rot on the ground. Paulk is one of the owners of the family-run farm where Rojas picks blackberries. He said he’s lost about $200,000 this blackberry season mainly because of Georgia’s new law.

But what bothers Paulk more than his financial loss, is how the law is punitive.

“Having a fake ID, a first-time offense can be up to 10 years, and $100,000 fine,” Paulk said. “I mean that’s, that’s like a felony. A felony to use a fake id to get a job to support your family.”

And what drove many workers to not come to Paulk’s fields this blackberry season is a fear that police would have increased power in immigration matters.

Javier Guerrero, a contractor who recruits workers for the farm, had a really hard time finding any migrant workers this year. Guerrero even went to Florida to try and recruit.

“I went to three or four places over there, and I don’t bring not even one,” he said. “A few call me when they find out about how the law was going to be here, they scared, they don’t come.”

(photo: Kristian Weatherspoon)

Paulk is glad that a federal judge temporarily blocked two key provisions of the Georgia law this week, and he hopes the hold will keep workers on his fields. But it may be too little too later for him.

“Well, I think the damage, in my opinion, has already been done, because there’s so much hearsay, you know,” he said.

The blackberry harvesting season is almost over. Now it’s on to muscadine grapes. Paulk’s curious to see how many workers he’ll get to pick them later this summer. The grapes are his main crop.

Discussion

23 comments for “Georgia Businesses Suffering from State Immigration Law”

  • Valerie Hess

    Where are all the welfare recipients in Georgia? Couldn’t they be filling in for the missing undocumented workers?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EKFBKQDYTGXQOIXFVC2EAQN7XI Robert

      Picking produce is a skill. You can’t just throw welfare recipients, parolees, or prisoners in a field and expect them to work effectively. And most wouldn’t last a day in the Georgia summer sun. We need these immigrants to do this work that we can’t and won’t. The politicians that passed this law were either too stupid or full of hate to consider the consequences.

      • Anonymous

         the politicians are lokoing out for the majority in the state who are tired of hearing about illegals, the crimes they commit, and im sure the people of georgia are tired of hearing what it costs the state every damn year. it has nothing to do with hate or being stupid. its about rule of law.
        Being illegal does not care where you came from, who you are, if you are rich or poor, illegal is illegal.
        i say put those prisoners out there and let them pick. instead of sititng in a cell thats air conditioned, getting three free meals a day that the taxpayers pay for. put them to work!

        • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=533376066 Janet Figueroa

          the only reasons why there is a ‘waste of money’ as you have put it on undocumented immigrants being detained is not b/c of their fault. Do you think they like being detained for months and months away from their family, wasting their time there while the state holds them there until they process their case? It’s not their choice. ITS YOUR STATE’S AND THATS HOW THE STATE WASTES YOUR MONEY. YOU SHOULD PROTEST THE WAY THE SYSTEM WORKS.. NOT TO THE VICTIMS OF IT.

          • Andrew Richards

            So we should just release all suspected criminals onto the streets until their case is heard, right?  Makes perfectly good sense to me.  You should run for president!

          • Andrew Richards

            So we should just release all suspected criminals onto the streets until their case is heard, right?  Makes perfectly good sense to me.  You should run for president!

      • Anonymous

         the politicians are lokoing out for the majority in the state who are tired of hearing about illegals, the crimes they commit, and im sure the people of georgia are tired of hearing what it costs the state every damn year. it has nothing to do with hate or being stupid. its about rule of law.
        Being illegal does not care where you came from, who you are, if you are rich or poor, illegal is illegal.
        i say put those prisoners out there and let them pick. instead of sititng in a cell thats air conditioned, getting three free meals a day that the taxpayers pay for. put them to work!

      • Anonymous

         the politicians are lokoing out for the majority in the state who are tired of hearing about illegals, the crimes they commit, and im sure the people of georgia are tired of hearing what it costs the state every damn year. it has nothing to do with hate or being stupid. its about rule of law.
        Being illegal does not care where you came from, who you are, if you are rich or poor, illegal is illegal.
        i say put those prisoners out there and let them pick. instead of sititng in a cell thats air conditioned, getting three free meals a day that the taxpayers pay for. put them to work!

      • Anonymous

         the politicians are lokoing out for the majority in the state who are tired of hearing about illegals, the crimes they commit, and im sure the people of georgia are tired of hearing what it costs the state every damn year. it has nothing to do with hate or being stupid. its about rule of law.
        Being illegal does not care where you came from, who you are, if you are rich or poor, illegal is illegal.
        i say put those prisoners out there and let them pick. instead of sititng in a cell thats air conditioned, getting three free meals a day that the taxpayers pay for. put them to work!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4D4NS7ZSYDFBEEGO4PT3TJ4ZVA El

    It’s easy to say “all the lazy people in Ga should get out in the field! (parolees, probationers, welfare recipients)” It’s even easier to say when YOU don’t have to get out there and work and provide for a family. The work these immigrants do is essential to Ga’s economy and it is a necessity that provides FOOD for people like you and me to go to Wal Mart and put in our buggies. If a man/woman is willing to work honestly: THEN LET THEM WORK!

    • Anonymous

       remember, there is a BIG difference between legal immigrants and illegal immigrants

    • Anonymous

       remember, there is a BIG difference between legal immigrants and illegal immigrants

    • Anonymous

       remember, there is a BIG difference between legal immigrants and illegal immigrants

    • Anonymous

       remember, there is a BIG difference between legal immigrants and illegal immigrants

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dustin-Goble/1088331306 Dustin Goble

      “If a man/woman is willing to work honestly: THEN LET THEM WORK!”

      That’s just it though. Illegal immigrants aren’t working honestly. Fake documentation, manipulating the system to get free health care and education, and getting paid under the table tax free isn’t really honest now, is it?

  • Anonymous

    maybe they should stop relying on undocumented, (illegal aliens) for a work force then they would not have that problem, now, would they

  • Anonymous

    maybe they should stop relying on undocumented, (illegal aliens) for a work force then they would not have that problem, now, would they

  • Anonymous

    maybe they should stop relying on undocumented, (illegal aliens) for a work force then they would not have that problem, now, would they

  • Anonymous

    maybe they should stop relying on undocumented, (illegal aliens) for a work force then they would not have that problem, now, would they

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=533376066 Janet Figueroa

    the problem is jamesw62 that undocumented immigrants are the only ones willing to do that job. duh. if these jobs weren’t available with no one to fill them then there wouldnt be illegal immigrants doing them now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=533376066 Janet Figueroa

    the problem is jamesw62 that undocumented immigrants are the only ones willing to do that job. duh. if these jobs weren’t available with no one to fill them then there wouldnt be illegal immigrants doing them now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=533376066 Janet Figueroa

    the problem is jamesw62 that undocumented immigrants are the only ones willing to do that job. duh. if these jobs weren’t available with no one to fill them then there wouldnt be illegal immigrants doing them now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sissycrazy Sissy Rigdon

    farmers can get off their wallets. an pay some money for others to work. an they wouldnt have those problems!!!!