Why Foreign Students are Hired for Alaskan Fish Processing Jobs

Processing fish at Snopac Products (photo: Nancy Blakey, co-owner of Snopac)

Processing fish at Snopac Products (photo: Nancy Blakey, co-owner of Snopac)

By Daysha Eaton of KDLG

At the dock at the Sno-Pac fish processing plant in Dillingham, Alaska, boats deliver thousands of salmon per day. American college students used to stand along these assembly lines. But now, you’re more likely to hear people speaking Russian, Spanish or Chinese.

Here in Bristol Bay, globalization has transformed fish processing plants over the last couple of decades. Most of the workers now are foreign students, on J-1student visas, designed for cultural exchange and training.

Many people probably wouldn’t put fish gutting into those categories, but the workers are allowed in under the work-travel option of the visa.

Mache Kazubovsky, a student at the University of Warsaw in Poland, said he paid around $3,000 to a recruiting agent to set him up with the job at Sno-pac. When the salmon are running, Kazubovsky works 16-hours a day with time-and-a-half for overtime. He earned minimum wage, but his room and board are covered. Kazubovsky hopes to double his initial investment, and then take a cross-country trip.

Another worker here is Hoy-Juhw, from Mainland China. She is studying applied linguistics back home and plans to be a teacher. Like Kazubovsky, she’s here to travel.

“I want to see New York and Washington, DC, the most famous cities, everyone has to see,” Hoy-Juhw said. “Most of all I want to experience what is real American life. I mean, not the one in a factory in Alaska, but the real American life on the mainland, in the big cities.”

The J-1 student workers have been a godsend for Nancy Blakey, co-owner of Sno-Pac.

“They’re educated, they’re bright, and they’re working really hard, long hours,” Blakey said.

Alaska fish processors started hiring J-1 students in the 1990s when unemployment was low and they couldn’t find American workers. The J-1′s are not just hard workers, Blakey said; they’re also really interesting.

“We had a young man come through who was studying nuclear physics. And we were talking, and he loved the beauty of nuclear physics. He was passionate and he was explaining it to me, in his limited English and doing very well. And he was going to be going out to gut fish. I think that’s pretty fantastic!”

Brad Gillespy does not think the J-1 program is fantastic. He’s regional manager for the Alaska Department of Labor in Anchorage.

“It just doesn’t appear to me the program is working the way it was intended,” Gillespy said. “If it is working the way it was intended, it’s having a negative impact on US and Alaska workers. If you’re in a rural community that’s got a plant or two and that’s one of the major employers there and they’re bringing in all outside workers, there’s got to be an impact on those individuals not being able to get on at those plants.”

Blakey said Sno-Pac has hireed locals for skilled positions, like truck drivers and heavy machinery operators, but few locals apply for the jobs that the J-1′s do. Sno-Pac also recruits on a website aimed at American college students. But she said she doesn’t get many responses.

Back at the plant, Alexander Esbinoff, from Ukraine, who’s back for his second year, told me this year he has a new job, working in the laundry.

In Esbinoff”s mind, he’s moving up, which is something he said is hard for a college kid to do in Ukraine.

“In summer in my country we just party, drink and smoke and that’s all,” Esbinoff said. “Here you can work up to the scale you are, I can earn money and I can improve my knowledge.”

Esbinoff hopes to clear $8,000 this summer and then take a trip to Hawaii before heading home to Kiev to finish his degree. But he’s thinking of coming back for a third season next year.

Discussion

10 comments for “Why Foreign Students are Hired for Alaskan Fish Processing Jobs”

  • Grace Thornton

    The pay an American student could earn working in a cannery used to be enough to pay for college in this country but now that just doesn’t cut it. Most people who come from other counties can make significantly more than any job at home. Once of the J-1 students I met years ago said he makes more than his father does teaching at the college level in Prague for a season of work.
    25 years ago the pay was about $6.50 starting. Last time I inquired 5 years ago, it was just $7.00 per hour. Not much of an increase for 20 yrs.  Its no wonder, like many other professions, American youth don’t want those jobs. The long hours, dirty work, horrible living conditions and being so far from home are just some of the other factors. For foreign workers its a chance to travel, make some money, see the states and go home with something in their pockets. The corporate profit margins are higher with this arrangement. Its a win win.
    Kind of sad but it is the way of the global economy.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Pamela-Kennedy/100001233602883 Pamela Kennedy

      Americans WOULD want these jobs if we could GET them. Native Americans are the last thing factory jobs like this want these days. One more thing that would rather sponsor working visas for foreigners than hire the local aboriginals standing right in front of them.

      • Liz G.

        one of the requirements to get J1 worker visa, or the h1-a h1-b for example are required by the department of labor to first place a newspaper ad that they are hiring, they send the results to the department of labor, if there was no willing, able, or available workers, then they are approved for the visa, the american workers are given the first opportunity to get these jobs but just like landscaping, marine welding, roofing, no one wants them. the visas are highly regulated and a benefit to this country

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Pamela-Kennedy/100001233602883 Pamela Kennedy

      Americans WOULD want these jobs if we could GET them. Native Americans are the last thing factory jobs like this want these days. One more thing that would rather sponsor working visas for foreigners than hire the local aboriginals standing right in front of them.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Pamela-Kennedy/100001233602883 Pamela Kennedy

    I”m also wondering how these foreigners are coming up with the required “work” references, since that’s the barrier when they advertise to Americans. Or are the foreigners allowed to use “character” and “personal” references, again, things Americans aren’t allowed to use. When I look at the AlexSys system under “fish processing” time after time the job description says “reference check.” Nowadays they’re also saying “no transportation, no relocation, no room and board allowance” as in they want local residents only who have work references that can be checked. And then they complain that they can’t find any “qualified” American citizens so they then go recruit foreigners on student visas….

    • Liz G.

      there’s a marine school

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y3PDVWZ3DVZXTSKYX36JQQE274 Volodymyr Rakshanov

    needed job

     

     

    To: permanent residents of USA (or residents with green cards), the
    family (45&55 years) is looking for any job with the separate room to live
    in.

    We look forward to hearing for you and thank you!

    e–mail: rakshanov.2011@mail.ru

    skype: rakshanov.2011

    Helen&William

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ruslan-Lysak/1063426369 Ruslan Lysak

    Here are some additional reasons why employers from Alaska hire J1-visa students:
    - You cover your seasonal staffing needs with young, highly motivated, English-speaking staff from 18 to 28 years old and cut costs by paying fewer taxes.
    - You diversify the environment of your venue by adding a multicultural flavor.
    - You get industrious, caring, sociable international workers who are committed to contributing and learning.
    - You avoid trouble and paperwork by reviewing applications of reliable, pre-screened candidates which we send to you.
    - You benefit from our years of experience in hiring exchange students for all kinds of Alaskan enterprises….
    Source: http://www.jobofer.org/alaskajobs/

  • Jacque Quinene

    I worked in a small plant in SE Alaska to pay my way through college as a deck hand and then as the Office Manager. We tried at first to hire locals, and about 90% of them would show up late, show up inebriated, or not show up at all. Then we tried recruiting kids from colleges around WA state – we didn’t get a very good turn out (we were paying for travel to/from AK as well as meals and boarding). The ones that did come up often didn’t last the season, or weren’t very hard workers. Finally we heard about the J1 program from another plant in Bristol Bay. We hired about 30 J1 workers from Serbia, Bulgaria, Turkey, Russia, Solvakia and Czech Republics. These were the BEST workers that we had. They worked their butts off and never complained or thought pulling guts from a dead salmon was beneath them.. as many of my fellow American college students did. 

    As someone who saw, first hand the unemployment and poverty in parts of Alaska that the locals deal with… I still don’t believe that J1 students are taking away jobs from locals of Alaska. Many (not all, I’m not generalizing, just speaking from my experience) of the local labor force in the towns our plant was in didn’t want to be on the slime line, or just wouldn’t show up. When you bring in workers that have nothing else to do but work, it makes plant life much better. 

  • Zaza Petriashvili

    Hello, how is possible to get the job in Fish Factory to Alaska, I m from Georgia ExSovietUnion country,my English is quite good.
    please contact me on my Email Zazapeterson@gmail.com