Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell is a Jerusalem-based Middle East reporter. He has been with The World since 2001 and has filed stories from cities across the US and abroad.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

We Heart You Iran: Israeli Couple’s Facebook Campaign Against Attack

"We will never bomb your country" (Photo: Pushpin Mehina/Facebook)
Speculation that Israel could soon attack Iran has dominated the Israeli news media in recent months.

For the first time, Israelis went out to protest on Saturday night against an attack on Iran. About a thousand people turned up for the demonstration in Tel Aviv. Intentionally or not, the event got a boost from a couple who launched an anti-war campaign on Facebook a little over a week ago.

Israeli teacher and graphic designer, Rony Edry, 41, says he didn’t plan on launching a movement of any kind. But one thing just led to another. Edry designed a poster, picturing himself standing in a white shirt, holding his 4 year-old daughter with an Israeli flag in her hand. Written below them in big print is the message: “Iranians. We will never bomb your country. We love you.”

“At the beginning,” Edry told me the other day in Tel Aviv, “the response [was] negative.” He said people were put off. They thought he was trying to speak for all Israelis. But that was not the intention, he said. It was meant to be simple person-to-person online outreach. And in any case, a flood of positive responses began pouring in soon enough. And it hasn’t stopped.

Edry said Israeli friends saw his poster on Facebook and asked him to make one with their pictures on it. The idea caught on. Dozens and then, hundreds and then, thousands of people connected with the Facebook group. Soon, Iranians even started to notice.

Edry talked with me on a busy pedestrian path, as a few of his design students shot some video nearby. Edry’s partner, Michal Tamir, 35, and their toddler, were there too. The couple seems to be embracing the idea of being part of genuine anti-war campaign that started with a simple, even naïve, question.

“Just talk with the other side,” Edry said while holding his sleepy son on his hip. “Like, ‘you sure we’re gonna do this?’”

The craziest thing happened, Edry said. Iranians responded by saying things like, “we don’t want to do it either.”

Edry said, if you had asked a week ago whether an online anti-war campaign could prevent a war, he would have had his doubts. “But now,” he said. “It’s so refreshing, you know, just to say, ‘I love you. I don’t want war with you.’”

“Maybe, it changed [some] minds.”

The truth is, Israelis are not of one mind when it comes to the question of using military force against Iran’s nuclear program. Prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has talked about it in terms of preventing another Holocaust. But some prominent Israelis, including high-level former intelligence officials, are against a unilateral Israeli attack. They warn that it could set off a dangerous regional conflict.

The public is divided too. One new poll found 60 percent of respondents saying they believed only military action could stop Iran’s nuclear progress. But in another survey of Jewish Israelis, 60 percent said they opposed an Israeli attack without US cooperation.

In such a contentious atmosphere, and with the stakes so high, an anti-war campaign on Facebook and Youtube is not likely to be a game-changer, said Meir Javedanfar. He is an Iranian-born Israeli citizen, and an Iran expert based in Tel Aviv. But Javedanfar has followed Edry’s campaign and applauds what he and his colleagues are doing.

“I think these guys show that we have a lot of intelligent people in Israel who don’t accept everything at face value,” Javedanfar said. “They, much like other Israelis, don’t want a nuclear Iran, are against the regime’s policies toward Israel, but don’t want to make 73 million enemies in Iran. They want to make 73 million friends in Iran.”

Besides, Javadanfar said the last thing the Iranian regime wants is for its public to begin to question three decades of propaganda that has demonized Israelis.




Visualize tweets for this story: Click on the image below to see tweets

spot-israel-iran


Discussion

5 comments for “We Heart You Iran: Israeli Couple’s Facebook Campaign Against Attack”

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/5NAL2BLHCNXSDEWAPTV2JYZ6II Adam

    In Israel, you have the freedom to say “Iran, We Love You”.  In Iran, saying the same about Israel would send you to the gallows.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HJCI7X475NRXONSYAVZWOFK6HI Jennifer

    Adam, right you are. Somehow The World (let alone the BBC) never tell us of the constant public calls in Iran for Israel’s destruction. Nor of the boast of several Iranian leaders that just one bomb will do the job. Nor of the shouts of “death to America”, “death to Israel”, led by Iranian leaders, at public meetings. Nor of Iran’s numerous other actions – attacking its Arab, Kurdish minorities, arming Iraqi insurgents, aiding Hamas, Hezbollah, … .

  • http://twitter.com/arrowhart arrowhart

    deep blue sea baby
    deep blue sea 

    deep blue sea baby 
    deep blue sea

    we pray for peace in all the land 
    and o’er the deep blue sea

    yesterday war clouds hung so low
    yesterday war clouds hung so low
    yesterday war clouds hung so low

    we pray for peace in all the land 
    and o’er the deep blue see

    Love of Life finally turns the key
    Love of Life finally turns the key
    Love of Life finally turns the key

    And Now there’s peace in all the land
    and O’er the Deep Blue Sea

    And Now there’s peace in all the land 
    and O’er the Deep Blue Sea

  • Margaret Fairchild

    The only power which wants war between Iran and Israel (the true purpose is to get a war between Russian and U.S.) is the British Oligarchy. And Obama, their willing puppet, would happily oblige, as would Loony-Tune Netanyahu.

    Most Israelis, including the Military, and most Irananians, DO NOT WANT WAR!

    To the Israeli “We Heart iran” movement-Bless you, and Mazel Tov!

    Maggie Fairchild (nee Silver)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Adam-Kegel/547627582 Adam Kegel

    There seems to have always been someone or some country or some cult such as
    the KKK that wants to annihilate Israel & the Jewish people. Iran’s
    president  Mahmoud Ahmedinajad is no friend or fan of the jewish people &
    neither are Hamas or Hezbollah who Mahmoud Ahmedinajad finances.
     
         We live in a crazy “FUCKED UP” world with crazy dictators, crazy
    leaders of government that cause a lot of ugliness & a lot of hate in the
    world..There’s a lot more hate & ugliness in the world than there is love
    & kindness.
     
      Unconditional love is the ability to send love in response to hate, in
    response to anger, in response to fear, but how many human beings can live that
    way? I commend you Rony for your good intentions by extending  the
    love to all Iranians with the hope that all Iranians will reciprocate..I’m sure
    some of them will but I highly doubt that Mahmoud Ahmedinajad will & neither
    will Hamas or Hezbollah…
     
           It’s been said that hatred is a lower & slower form of energy if
    you measured it compared to love which is a higher & faster form of energy.
    A good metaphor for this would be the following.> Take a room filled with
    darkness, it is a lower & slower form of energy if you measure it compared
    to a room filled with light. Therefore a dark room equals hatred. A lit room
    equals love. If you open the lights in a dark room the darkness, (hatred) disappears.
     
             I often feel the same way the character “John Coffey” portrayed by
    Michael Clarke Duncan in the green mile where he said the
    following> ” I’m tired, boss. Mostly I’m tired of people being ugly to each
    other. I’m tired of all the pain I feel and hear in the world everyday. There’s
    too much of it. It’s like pieces of glass in my head all the time. Can you
    understand?”  >  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ScHhuIY4Pwo

     

        ABOUT > President Mahmoud Ahmedinajad

     Suppression Continues in Iran

     

    President Mahmoud Ahmedinajad

     

    Born: 1956

     

    Hometown: GarmsarSemnan

     

    Position: President of the Islamic Republic

     

          Favorite expression or quotation by President Mahmoud Ahmedinajad
    >

     

    “Now… dirt or dust creeping from the corners may do something. But you must
    know that the pure river that is the Iranian nation will not allow them to put
    themselves on display.”

     

           My two cents…     Adam Kegel ( Child of Holocaust survivors)