Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell

Matthew Bell is a Jerusalem-based Middle East reporter. He has been with The World since 2001 and has filed stories from cities across the US and abroad.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

Israel Celebrates Remembrance Day

It's a rare sight for Jewish and Arab students in Jerusalem to come together to mark Israeli Memorial Day. (Photo: Matthew Bell)

It's a rare sight for Jewish and Arab students in Jerusalem to come together to mark Israeli Memorial Day. (Photo: Matthew Bell)

See a slideshow from Remembrance Day here.

Israelis are celebrating their two biggest state holidays this week. They go together: Independence Day is Thursday. That’s the day Israel declared itself an independent state.

Wednesday is Remembrance Day, when Jewish Israelis come together to mourn the deaths of fallen soldiers and victims of terrorism.

But the day also highlights deep divisions between Israel and the Palestinians, even for those trying to promote peaceful co-existence between the two sides.

About 2,000 people took part in an “alternative” memorial day event last night in Tel Aviv. The idea was to honor all people who died in the Mideast conflict, both Israeli and Palestinian.

A group called “Combatants for Peace” organized the event. They’re former Israeli soldiers and Palestinian militants. Mohammad Aweida is a Palestinian from East Jerusalem who spent time in an Israeli jail. Even on this difficult day of the year, he says, Jews and Arabs still share the experience of loss and pain for all those who’ve died. Aweida said this ceremony is about building mutual respect.

“If you respect your enemy, he will respect you,” Aweida said. “Then, you will go to solution. But if you hide from him, and you will afraid from him, you will never go to solution.”

Sitting next to one of his Jewish Israeli colleagues and a fellow activist, Aweida said the current political stalemate is working against them. Negotiations are stuck, he said, and then there’s ongoing Jewish settlement building in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

“There is no peace. And there is no conversation. And the settlement is making my work and his work so difficult. Because, what can I tell my people and what he can tell his people? Everything is frozen,” he said.

Aweida concedes that many Palestinians would condemn him for taking part in a public event with Israelis while the occupation continues.

And just outside, there was more disapproval. A couple of dozen protesters waved Israeli flags and denounced the Tel Aviv ceremony for glorifying terrorists.

In a speech in Jerusalem on Wednesday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu talked about national unity on this Memorial Day. But what makes that so difficult, are two profoundly conflicting narratives about these two days of national reflection. While Israelis commemorated Memorial Day Wednesday, and will celebrate Independence Day Thursday, Palestinians mark the 1948 anniversary of the founding of Israel as their “Nakba,” or catastrophe.

The Hand in Hand school in Jerusalem – Kindergarten through 12th grade – is one of the few places in Israel where Jewish and Arab kids go to school together. The place is all about promoting co-existence, and that makes Memorial Day tricky.

A mixed high school class of Arab and Jewish students discusses a documentary they just viewed about a suicide bombing. The idea is to let the students deal with tough issues through dialogue, said education director Inas Deeb. But she called today, “a very difficult day.”

“We’re still in a process. We try to learn what is the best way, what is the right way, what is the most relevant way,” Deeb said. “But it’s very tense. We have to allow ourselves to accept each others feelings, to talk about them. And this is difficult. But getting them together now does not mean that we solve everything.”

Deeb said this is the only day of the year students here are divided up. Jews attend one ceremony while Arabs have separate activities. But they are careful to end the day together, by gathering in the courtyard to release a heart-shaped balloon with the word “Love” on it.


Discussion

4 comments for “Israel Celebrates Remembrance Day”

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    The PA is increasing its anti-Israel agitation – just see the article by
    Israeli Arab journalist Khaled Abu Toameh, “Palestinian Authority
    Radicalizing Palestinians, Dragging Them Toward War”

    http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/3028/palestinian-authority-radicalizing-palestinians

    He is also a columnist for the Jerusalem Post.

    The PA has sentenced to death a Palestinian that sold Jews a  plot in
    Hebron (actually land adjacent to the Jewish quarter and apparently
    occupied by Jews until the 1929 Hebron massacre of Hebron’s Jews). See

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2134245/Former-Palestinian-intelligence-officer-sentenced-death-selling-home-Jews.html

    Will this attract one tenth as much attention as Jews daring to live on
    the West Bank? Will there ever be any mention of the contradiction that
    it is OK for 1.25 million Israeli Arabs to live within Israel, yet it is
    not OK for Jews to live on land they bought or legally acquired in the
    West Bank? 

    • KKRDB

      Just think,if the arabs had not  faught,nascent Israel  trying to throw them into the sea?At the time of the mandate,they would have joined forces with the Jews what a wonderful grand country would it have been.
       
      Living in harmony building even a more prosperous country than Singapore.
      No attacks,no deats, no killings,no hate .
      Alas that is not how it ended

      Even at the Dome of the Rock Jews could have entered as guests without any problem.

      There now…The hate permeated by Arabs(all) has been to their detriment,
      not  to Jews.

      Who irrespectively flourish,while the others live in mentally deficiencies

      I suppose it takes courage & the Arab mindset has no ability in its precepts
      to acknowlege it.  
       

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    There was not a hint in the entire report that negotiations have been
    stuck for years, because the PA has refused to negotiate without
    preconditions that determine the outcome of negotiations, and amount to
    Israeli surrender.

    There was not a hint in the entire report that Palestinians have
    repeatedly rejected any solution that allows a PERMANENT Israel behind
    any boundaries, nor of the repeated wars launched by the Arab world to
    destroy Israel. There was not a hint that it was the Palestinian
    themselves, and the Arab world that rejected a two-state solution in
    1948, 1967 – nor that Arafat rejected a workable solution in 2001, and
    his successor Abbas did the same in 2008, 2010.

    Why do you always talk of “settlements” as if that is the real core
    issue? Why do you omit any mention of repeated Palestinian statements
    that they will destroy Israel step by step? Why not mention that Abbas
    has rejected negotiations in favor of unilateral statehood without peace
    - and then to accelerate the conflict?

     

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y6L6FTDBJYFKOHEZCN6BO6ZEGQ dorn

    How long will it take The World to tell the other side?

    (1) Of the Jewish refugees from Arab lands, whose descendants form more than half of Israel’s population;

    (2) Of the core issue, namely Arab refusal to accept Jewish self determination, behind any boundaries;

    (3) Of the constant incitement in PA and Hamas TV, in their schools and mosques;

    (4) That Arab regimes waged war long before “settlements”, and that
    if there weren’t any, they would still wage war based on some other
    pretext;

    (5) Of Hamas’ charter, which is comparable to  Mein Kampf in its virulence;

    (6) Of the PA naming streets, town squares, and youth camps after perpetrators of the worst terror attacks;

    (7) Of the ancient Jewish communities that formed a majority in East Jerusalem prior to the 1920′s when Jews were driven out;

    (8) Of the Jewish community of Hebron that was massacred in 1929;

    (9) Why is it wrong for Jews to live in the West Bank on land they
    bought or owned, yet OK for 1.25 million Israeli Arabs to live as
    Israeli citizens?

    (10) Of Jordan’s Civil Law no. 6, which explicitly excludes Jews
    from citizenship; and Jordan’s Bedouin dominated government that
    suppresses its Palestinian majority.

    (11) Of the corruption and lack of press freedom within the PA and Gaza, Jordan, …