Ari Daniel Shapiro

Ari Daniel Shapiro

Reporter Ari Daniel Shapiro used to listen to seals and whales during his research training as an oceanographer. These days, he listens to people, and he uses radio and multimedia to tell stories about science and the environment.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

Clean Cookstoves Protect Women and the Environment

Getting individuals to change their behavior for the good of the planet can be a hard sell. Whether it’s encouraging homeowners to use compact fluorescent bulbs or convincing drivers to buy hybrid cars, environmentalists have learned that the best approach is often an appeal to self-interest. That’s the tactic an environmental group in Africa is using to persuade women to change the way they cook. Ari Daniel Shapiro of our partner program NOVA has the story from Uganda.


Sister Bridget Kokiambo rests a pot on top of three stones the size of bowling balls. She’s in the small, dark kitchen of Providence Home, a school and residence for those with disabilities in the Ugandan village of Nkokonjeru.

She points to the space in between the stones. That’s where the firewood goes.

“We make the fire so that it can burn and cook,” she says.

The inside walls are black with soot. “There is no pipe to take out the smoke,” she explains.

A woman in Ghana cooks over a traditional, open fire. (Photo courtesy of the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves)

A woman in Ghana cooks over a traditional, open fire. (Photo courtesy of the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves)

This is how nearly 3 billion people in the developing world cook their food and heat their homes, with dirty, inefficient stoves that billow smoke. They cause health problems – such as emphysema, heart disease, and lung cancer – for those who use them.

The black soot is also bad for the climate; it’s a greenhouse pollutant that helps warm the planet. And because these stoves are inefficient, they require a lot of firewood, which contributes to deforestation.

One solution that’s being promoted here and elsewhere is a cleaner cookstove.

Clearing the Air

Confrio Nsubuga works for an environmental group in Uganda called JEEP (Joint Energy and Environment Projects). It’s one of many organizations in the developing world that are promoting more efficient cookstoves.

An example of the efficient cookstove being promoted by the Ugandan environmental group JEEP. (Photo: Ari Daniel Shapiro)

An example of the efficient cookstove being promoted by the Ugandan environmental group JEEP. (Photo: Ari Daniel Shapiro)

Nsubuga’s version sits in the corner of his kitchen in the village of Bumbajja. His wife blows on the kindling, and the flames flare up, lapping at the wood.

“What makes it efficient is the way it is constructed,” he says.

The stove is nothing fancy. In fact, Nsubuga’s organization doesn’t sell the stoves. It teaches people to build them.

The stove is made from clay. It’s squat and rectangular. A couple of pots sit on top, and there’s a hole at the base where the firewood goes.

“As you see now, there is only one piece of firewood,” he says.

A single piece of firewood can heat up the whole unit, so the stove is energy-efficient, and no smoke wafts into the kitchen. It’s all diverted through an aluminum chimney.

This stove may be better for the environment, but it’s different from what locals are accustomed to, so getting people to use it can be a challenge.

“There may be well-intentioned individuals and organizations that have developed good, clean, efficient stoves, but they haven’t taken into account how those stoves may be used on a day-to-day basis,” says Radha Muthiah, executive director of the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves.

Some people resist switching to the new stoves because they believe that food tastes better when cooked over a traditional, open fire.

Less Wood, More Security

In Uganda, Confrio Nsubuga has noticed that people can be reluctant to adopt his clean cookstoves, so he’s trying a different tactic to convince women to make the switch. He’s pitching the clean cookstoves not as a way to protect the environment, but as a way for women to protect themselves.

To explain, he escorts me into the forest behind his home at dusk.

“This is where people get firewood,” he says.

The forest is dark and filled with the sounds of insects. We peer through the trees and can just make out someone using an axe to cut down branches and tree trunks.

Nsubuga says it’s usually women and children who collect firewood in the forests, and this can be a dangerous place for them.

The greenery is so thick, someone could easily hide and watch you. And the din of the forest masks even nearby sounds.

Inside forests like this, rape and sexual assault are common. In one region of Uganda, 20 to 30 percent of gender-based violence incidents are estimated to occur when women are out collecting firewood.

“So if you have a more efficient stove, then that certainly reduces the number of times that the women have to go out and make that trek,” says Muthiah of the Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves.

And this is one way the Ugandan environmental group JEEP is promoting its clean stoves. It says they translate into less time in the forest, which means a lower risk of rape and sexual assault.

Jane Nambuli (back, center) stands in front of her home with her daughter and four granddaughters. (Photo: Ari Daniel Shapiro)

Jane Nambuli (back, center) stands in front of her home with her daughter and four granddaughters. (Photo: Ari Daniel Shapiro)

The argument appealed to 65-year-old Jane Nambuli, who lives down the road from the forest in Bumbajja.

“I used to go in the forest to fetch the firewood,” she says, “but I thought that I might be raped because most of the women, we are raped.”

Now Nambuli has one of the new stoves, and she says she feels safer. In fact, she uses so little wood that she’s able to grow most of what she needs in her own yard.

Nambuli smiles as she lifts a cover made of banana leaves off a pot on her new stove. Inside there’s rice and sweet potatoes, which she and her family have just eaten for lunch. The food is hot, the air inside her home is clean, and she didn’t have to venture into the forest.

Discussion

5 comments for “Clean Cookstoves Protect Women and the Environment”

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Giulia-Latini/1263997393 Giulia Latini

    I was curious about the design of this stove and so did some research and came upon this blog, which you may want to read closely: 

    lemonadesoldiers.wordpress.com

  • http://www.facebook.com/aoife.wilson.1 Aoife Wilson

    Unfortunately the model of stove shown here has proven to be ineffective.
    In 2002, The Ugandan Ministry for Energy and Mineral Development, in conjunction with Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ), produced a report entitled ’A Comparison of Wood- Burning Cookstoves for Uganda: Testing and Development”. This report outlines the clear scientific evidence that the Lorena stove (which I believe is what is being described above) unfortunately does not do what it was made to do. In summary, 
    ‘Lorena and Dembe stoves are substantially less efficient at high power than a three-stone fire [the traditional method of cooking in this region]. They also have a higher fuel consumption for a 90 minute simmering test at low power, and for cooking a traditional Ugandan meal. They should not be promoted on the basis of fuel saving. The good reputation of the Lorena is due to a self-perpetuating myth………… since other stoves can offer the same additional benefits, such as smoke removal, they should be abandoned in favour of more efficient designs.’

    Sadly, articles like (which has already been ‘recommended’ and ‘shared’ multiple times) only help to perpetuate such myths and further promote bad practice. 

    If the organisation mentioned above are interested in improving their stove program, they could look into the Centre for Research in Energy and Energy Conservation which is based at Makerere University, Kampala (51km from their project in Nkoknjeru).
    This independent and internationally recognised stove testing centre uses globally accepted testing procedures. I learned so much from visiting them last year. They seem to have seen more failures and successes in stove design and implementation than anyone else so this puts them in an excellent position to assess how effective a potential project is likely to be.
    I also wrote a rough guide for NGOs or Community Based Organisations who are considering introducing such a project within their community. The guide outlines some of the main pitfalls and suggests how they can be avoided. Here’s the link http://lemonadesoldiers.wordpress.com/2011/09/22/info-for-community-based-organisations-intending-on-introducing-a-clean-cookstove-program/  

  • http://www.facebook.com/HarvestFlo Florence Reed

    We have had very good success with the Justa stove in Honduras and a new stove design created by our staff in Panama.  You can read about the Justa at http://www.sustainableharvest.org/techniques/wood-conserving-stoves and the DAMAK in Panama at http://www.sustainableharvest.org/news-articles/articles/newsletter-articles/origin-and-benefits-of-the-damak-wood-conserving-stove

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=516869858 Patricia Mcardle

    I also urge the author of this report to look at the article attached above that describes how retained heat baskets work. They are incredibly simple devices that anyone can make with locally available materials and which offer huge fuel savings.  The third device that Ugandan women can use is a solar cooker any day when the sun is shining–so they can save their scarce wood for use at night, early in the morning and on cloudy days.  There are many solar cooker projects in Uganda, which you can read about here:
    http://solarcooking.wikia.com/wiki/Uganda

  • Govind Sharma

    If you have not used your fireplace in a long time, pests may have built
    nests that could clog your flue or chimney chamber. Winter freeze
    cycles and moisture combine to take an annual toll on masonry and liner
    materials too.
    http://www.naglefireplaces.com/stoves