Monica Campbell

Monica Campbell

Monica Campbell is The World’s immigration editor/reporter. She is based in San Francisco and has reported for The World from Mexico, Cuba, Portugal and Afghanistan, as well as California.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

‘My Neighbourhood’: A Documentary on Property Rights Dispute in East Jerusalem

Mohammed El Kurd, whose story of eviction by Israeli settlers is told in the documentary "My Neighbourhood." (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

Mohammed El Kurd, whose story of eviction by Israeli settlers is told in the documentary "My Neighbourhood." (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

Recently, at San Francisco’s historic Castro Theater, a short documentary called “My Neighbourhood” had its West Coast premiere. Directed by Brazil’s Julia Bacha and Rebekah Winger-Jabi, it begins with a Palestinian teen, Mohammad El Kurd. In the film, he introduces his family and home in the Palestinian neighborhood of East Jerusalem.

“I live in Jerusalem in Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood,” Mohammad says. “This is my father. This is my library. I have lots of books.”

It’s a peaceful introduction. And then Mohammad’s life is upended.

Soon, we hear Mohammad’s grandmother shouting at Israeli settlers in 2009. They’d won the legal right to evict Mohammad’s family and his neighbors from homes they’ve lived in since 1956, part of an ongoing push by Jewish settlers for more control over Palestinian areas.

The film’s distinction is its focus on Mohammad, a bewildered 11-year-old living through it all. It’s a rare respective amid Israeli-Palestinian headlines.

In San Francisco, the film stirred complex feelings. Lois Jacobs, a nurse, was in the audience.

“I guess I have been more partial to the Israelis that are doing the occupying,” Jacobs said. “But after seeing this particular film it gives me a very painful feeling because I know that these families are being evicted from their home with all their possessions. And where do they go? What do they do? And it hurts me.”

It’s a response that Just Vision, the filmmaking group behind “My Neighbourhood,” hopes to elicit.

“You hear so often about this conflict but it’s translated into these broad political processes that people can’t really think of in tangible terms,” said Nadav Greenberg, the film’s associate producer. “Seeing someone kicked out of their home in the middle of the day, and then other families moving in in front of their very eyes is something that’s very difficult to remain indifferent to.”

In East Jerusalem, the film’s affected Mohammad, too. He’s 14 now, wants to become a human rights lawyer, and recently went to the documentary’s screening at the European Parliament in Brussels. In a phone interview from Jerusalem, he told me that it was a surreal, surprising journey.

Mohammad El Kurd and filmmaker Julia Bacha at a screening of the documentary "My Neighbourhood" in June at the European Parliament in Brussels. (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

Mohammad El Kurd and filmmaker Julia Bacha at a screening of the documentary "My Neighbourhood" in June at the European Parliament in Brussels. (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

“It’s my first time out of Middle East,” he said. “Also, when I went to the European Parliament, I thought it’s going to be really hard because I always think, I don’t know, they’re like politicians and what we see in the news, those mad faces and stuff. I just imagined they would all be, like, mad.”

The film does include claims by the Israeli settlers, sentiments held by an increasingly vocal and politically influential minority of Jews. In the film, a leader of the Jewish settlement movement said, “The Bible says that this area and this country belongs to the Jewish people. All this area will be a Jewish neighborhood.”

But the film focuses on the Palestinian experience and that included the shock of seeing Israelis from West Jerusalem also protest the evictions. When Mohammad first saw the protesters, he asked himself, ‘These are Jews?’”

“I was shocked,” he said. “I thought they’re Jews and Jews are bad and stuff. But no, I found out like most of the Jews are good.”

Greenberg, the film’s associate producer, who is from Jerusalem, was also there in 2009 and joined other Israelis defending the Palestinians. He says that “My Neighbourhood” also highlights a moment of Israeli-Palestinian solidarity, especially now.

“Things like evictions of families in East Jerusalem, things like growing settlements in East Jerusalem are pushing the city to the brink,” Greenberg said. “And if things explode in Jerusalem, things explode around the region.”

Zvi Benninga, an Israeli activist who protested against the eviction of Palestinian families in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah, a movement highlighted in the documentary "My Neighbourhood." (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

Zvi Benninga, an Israeli activist who protested against the eviction of Palestinian families in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah, a movement highlighted in the documentary "My Neighbourhood." (Photo: Emily Smith/Just Vision)

Since the evictions, Mohammad’s family, more than 10 relatives in all, have lived in a cramped annex. Bizarrely, it’s in the back of their former home, where settlers now live. Relations are poisoned. Mohammad said that he and his new neighbors never talk.

“Never,” he said. “When people say, ‘How’s your new neighbors?’ Like, they’re not neighbors. You know, when a virus comes to the body, they are just like small cancer and I know someday they will just go away.”

For now, Mohammad says he’s glad that a wider public can see his life and also know the story of the Israelis who came to his family’s side. It gives him strength, he says, when a resolution to his home life now still seems far away.


Discussion

22 comments for “‘My Neighbourhood’: A Documentary on Property Rights Dispute in East Jerusalem”

  • walt kovacs

    these arabs are the settlers, only claiming the land when jordan occupied it. that was an illegal occupation and they never had legal right to the land

    dont care what this kid thinks….he is a jordanian citizen…let them all go home

    • Alex Guenser

      I’m sure after the US is left to Native Americans and all other illegal occupiers leave, they may do that.

      Nobody cares what YOU think.

    • http://twitter.com/tomfen210 Tom Fenade

      @walt_kovacs:disqus…. @mjazzguitar:disqus
      Your reasoning’s are so pathetic!….bigots.

      • mjazzguitar

        After the ethnic cleansing of Jews in Judea and Samaria, and renaming it the “West Bank”, Jordan also destroyed 58 synagogues
        in Jerusalem’s Old City- it’s historical fact, not reasoning. No bigotry on Jordan’s part?

    • Nyakairu

      Most Jews in Israel came from Europe. Settling them in the Middle East was Europe’s solution to rid itself of Jews from its midst.

  • mjazzguitar

    I would bet that this was property that belonged to Jews who were expelled from the eastern part of Jerusalem when Jordan seized it.
    NPR is biased.

    • Nyakairu

      There was no Israel until 1948. How about the Jews in the contrived state going back where they came from?

      • mjazzguitar

        Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, and Jordan were also “contrived” out of the Ottoman Empire. The Zionists started purchasing land in the 1800s, irrigating the desert and draining malarial swamps. There’s no reason they shouldn’t have a state on land they purchased and developed. Israel only takes up 1/4 of 1% of the available land mass, yet the Jewish state is the only one whose legitimacy is questioned. Anti-semite much?

        • Nyakairu

          European Jews belong where they came from – Europe. There is nothing anti-Semitic about it. It makes no difference how little land Israel occupies, it remains a contrived state.

          • mjazzguitar

            The UN voted to make it a nation. In 1961, Kuwait became a nation. South Sudan became a nation last year. Do you want all blacks to return to Africa, and, for that matter, all the arabs to return to where they came from?

          • Nyakairu

            European Jews should be returned to Europe. They don’t belong in the Middle East. No group of people should be moved half way across the world to displace indigineous people from their land. Your argument is nonsensical and unconnected to how Israel was contrived.

          • mjazzguitar

            The UN voted to make it a a nation. It wasn’t contrived.

          • Nyakairu

            European countries in the UN voted for the creation of Israel to rid Europe of Jews. Why didn’t Europe create Israel in Europe?

          • mjazzguitar

            So should the Jews expelled from the surrounding arab countries be allowed to stay?

            What about the children of the European Jews?

            What about the children of Jews who were expelled from the arab countries that married European Jews?

          • Nyakairu

            I couldn’t care less what happens to them.

          • mjazzguitar

            Then they can stay.

  • mjazzguitar

    By the way, there’s no such entity as “East Jerusalem”. There is eastern Jerusalem, but it’s not two cities. (more NPR bias that the taxpayers pay for.)

  • copyleft

    Conveniently left out of the narrative is the fact that Mohammed El-Kurd’s (now that sounds like a very Arabic sounding name,doesn’t it? especially the Kurdish half of it!)
    family had been living in homes from which Jews had been forcefully expelled by Jordanian Arabs – the very proponents of multi-cultural existence, or so the NPR would have us all believe – and had steadfastly refused to pay any rent whatsoever all these years, even after the original owners had filed a suit for recovery of their property nearly 4 decades ago.

    In the inverted world of NPR and other Falsetinian friendlies, that constitutes a gross violation of human rights.Any wonder why many people now advocate flushing money down the toilet as a better alternative to sending it the NPR way?

  • Nyakairu

    Israel should be ashamed to let these racist Jewish settlers use Nazi tactics against the Palestinians.

    • mjazzguitar

      The arabs should be ashamed that they sided with the Nazis during World War Two.

      • Nyakairu

        Arabs have nothing to be ashamed of. Their only regret is not keeping out European Jews from the Middle East.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Doron-Lubinsky/12818660 Doron Lubinsky

    Monica Campbell omitted the most crucial detail in her31 August report on “My Neighborhood”: the property belongs to Jews, and those evicted had refused to pay rent for decades. The Israeli court system, which has bent over backwards to Arab claims, found that the property belongs to Jews evicted by the Jordanians. Why did she not mention this?