Anders Kelto

Anders Kelto

Anders Kelto is The World's Africa Correspondent. He is based in Cape Town, South Africa, and reports on health and development issues. Prior to joining The World, he worked with NPR, the CBC, and National Geographic.

  • |
  • ALL POSTS

Ethiopia’s Crowded Medical Schools

The pediatrics wing of St. Paul’s Hospital in Addis Ababa is a busy place. Nervous parents move in and out, waiting for their kids to be seen.

There aren’t a lot of doctors here, but there is one group of people that seems to be everywhere: young, white-coated medical students.

Until recently, Ethiopia had just one physician for every 100,000 people, but now the country is dramatically increasing the number of doctors it produces.

This year, the government opened 13 new medical schools, which more than doubled the number in the country. Ethiopia has also been increasing enrollment at existing schools.

“This year, for the first time, we enrolled 3,100 medical students, which is almost tenfold compared to what we used to enroll five, six years ago,” says Dr. Tedros Adhanom, Ethiopia’s foreign minister, who until recently served as minister of health.

Tedros says Ethiopia’s severe physician shortage is one of the country’s most pressing concerns.

Many doctors leave Ethiopia for higher-paying jobs overseas, and those who stay tend to work in the cities and in the private sector. That means the 85 percent of Ethiopians who live in rural villages may never see a doctor.

Tedros says the government’s solution is to deliberately overproduce doctors and flood the country with new physicians. “Even if you lose 100 or 200, everybody doesn’t migrate,” he says.

Dame Endalew is in his final year at St. Paul’s Medical College in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. (Photo: Anders Kelto)

Dame Endalew is in his final year at St. Paul’s Medical College in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. (Photo: Anders Kelto)

But some say this huge increase in the quantity of doctors is compromising quality.

Dame Endalew, a medical student at St. Paul’s, says the sharp increase in enrollment has made it difficult to learn.

“There’s a scarcity of resources,” Dame says. “We don’t have books, computer labs, lecturers. Every time the number of students increases, these things become worsened.”

Dame says he often can’t complete assignments because all of the books and computers are in use. He had to share a cadaver with 30 peers. And he often interviews patients who have already seen 10 or 15 other medical students.

“When you try to work with them, they are really fed up with the students asking the same question again and again,” he says.

But perhaps the biggest problem at Ethiopian medical schools is a shortage of instructors.

There are very few incentives for senior doctors to teach at medical schools. That means young doctors like Daniel Hailemariam, a professor of public health at the University of Addis Ababa, are asked to step in.

“I just graduated in July, and I’m currently enrolled as a faculty there,” he says, though he has never worked in the public health sector.

A classroom inside St. Paul’s Medical College, which has enrolled a growing number of students. (Photo: Anders Kelto)

A classroom inside St. Paul’s Medical College, which has enrolled a growing number of students. (Photo: Anders Kelto)

At Ethiopia’s 13 new medical schools there is also a shortage of professors, so recent graduates are often asked to teach. Some say that could cause big problems down the road.

One foreign doctor, who has worked in Ethiopia for more than 20 years, but asked not to be identified, said these new schools are producing a generation of doctors who don’t know what they’re doing, and they could do more harm than good.

Dr. Tedros Adhanom, Ethiopia’s former minister of health, agrees that physician quality is a concern, but he insists that Ethiopian schools will meet a minimum standard for medical education. And he says that’s good enough for now.

“I don’t think we will change this country by waiting until we get something perfect to start something,” Tedros says. “It cannot be perfect. We have to start with what we have.”


Discussion

6 comments for “Ethiopia’s Crowded Medical Schools”

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/V4ODEHOIEPI3CZ55UIGMWWDIOQ Tadele

    i afraid to say but i dont think the sistem in all ways running in ethiopia brings some changes , these guys with authority should see the other countries activity in all aspects, in fact teodros himself cant get the way to chande in health status in ethiopia, there is unworkable sistems planned in ethiopia specially in health, education ,politics which should have been planned very carefully as thse are the background on which the identity of the people is gonna build… when u think the answer given by tewodros to decrease the number of doctors migrating to other countries, he gives an answer that can never be a solution, he thought to solve the problem by increasing the number of students enrolling in medical school, but did he think the infarastractures for the students to be enrolled? what if all the students intend to leave their country? suppose there are a people who dont know how to ask for their rights, duties, and dont know any kind of social activities, i mean there is no change in ethiopia except some people earned after knowing that the able to read. for the people who do not get their besic necessities, i cant accuse them that they have to ask for the other rights…there is a lot of things to say but i dont thinkk so there is some one to listean to me and friends with same idea to me…yebesebese zinab ayiferam new negeru,sorry for our poeple getting vulnurable coz of those dump people on authority!

  • Chanyalew Adal

    I just wanted to point out the major problems we have in health sector in Ethiopia and what I feel right where the government has to re-focus on. Ethiopia is a country where millions travel to the capital city Addis Aaba, seeking a medicaton and special tretement and wait for months sleeping on the street and cold to get a medical attention, if they are lucky and did not pass away in the mean time before they got a chance to see a medical Doctors.
    The only two or three specialized and referal Hospitals we have in the capital could not accommodate all the patients coming from every angles of the country. Hence, we need more well equipped, staffed  referal hospitals at least two in all regions. Secondly, as the private and public medical schools are growing and massive out puts are coming up, the government has to change its Health Policy with regard to he health worker and physicians by providing them better pay, other benefits like specilized training abroad, good facilities of living and working areas and more incentives to retain them. Why we spend on them millions of public money  and we are  unabel to retain them ? No Ethiopian want to desert his/her  poor people and his /her beloved country, if they got all facilities and opportunities at home. We can not go further by the current pubilc health Policy with the growing demands and the evergrowing number of the people I guess. The Gov. need to review it and make a change. The Health sector need equal attention like other social and economic secotors (like Education) constructions, of roads,dams and buildigs underway. That is one of the parameter for development of the country I think.  The problem is the change of health policy from the upper echelon. In short, WE need more organized Health facilities  and well staffed and equipped training centers in all regional states and a policy that benefits all the physicians, medical workers and the people of Ethiopia by in large. There will no development successful without healthy populace.

  • allen321

    La plupart des gens ne comprennent pas que l’acné sur d’autres endroits, absurde peut se produire dans votre visage que vos épaules et robes mariée pas chères dos. Vous avez sérieusement besoin de l’étouffer, si elle arrive à votre avenir dans robes mariée pas chères marijuana. Lire au pair erdem nombreux traitement de l’acné ideas.A spéciale M possibilité de rester loin de l’acné poussées d’acné est généralement n ont un bon oreiller nuit de repos. Pensez-y un instant. Plus sérieusement, vous jetez et tourner avec lui tous les soirs. H loin de cette contamination par régulière ig laver les taies d’oreiller et utiliser une évidence que tous les remèdes night.Situation sont le meilleur choix pour nominales boutons d’acné. Avez-programme de traitement de l’espace poignée zone du foyer seulement. Effectuez une recherche pour les traitements, Salicyls ure, contiennent du peroxyde de benzoyle, le bicarbonate de soude ou de soufre. Regardez en ligne dans les yeux des remèdes maison naturels. Frottez votre affaire pi avec seulement de l’eau potable et à cesser d’utiliser les accessoires de synthèse r pendant un certain temps pour savoir si plus efficacement affiché de cette faon. Beaucoup de questions acné proviennent des produits cosmétiques utilisés par la victime. Détruisez cette esthétique rerisch pour les produits chimiques, le manquement en cause et de robes de mariages rendre plus facile pour les micro-organismes pour grow.Try à éviter avec Z dents blanchir les choses. Que ce soit dans le N Hé votre Mundh sélectionner h souvent des plaintes anf désinvolture sont, il peut être temps de chercher vos produits de soins dentaires sera. Certains bains de bouche, Z blanchiment des dents dentifrices et Z Déclaration des dents bandes tion acné choix pour les gens. Les pores de la peau w au cours de la Mundh hle est beaucoup plus sensible que robes de mariées pas cheres peau d’autres color.Make assurer que vous continuez vos hormones de l’homme en équilibre pour rester en bonne santé. Assurez-vous que vous maintenir efficacement vos organes. Les plus saines de vos organes internes, k beaucoup moins d’acné vous pouvez! Lorsque l’acné de votre mieux pour utiliser tout-naturel. Additifs et de conservateurs lourds dans les options k nombreux peut conduire à des irritations de la peau. Les additifs et les conservateurs k peut éliminer robe mariage en ligne peau des légumes le et de la peau Retirer l’obstacle de protection. Cela tend à compenser la couleur de votre peau et la rendre beaucoup plus l tr gt interrupteur pour faire acne.If beaucoup plus que vous souffrez du stress, il peut causer de l’acné. Pression provoque une hormone appelée cortisol sortie. Ces hormones humaines à des irritations de la peau et l’acné impts k nnte. Enquête sur les M possibilité, la tension peut gérer vous aider, rend pimples.Staying hydratée, votre couleur de peau pour garder l’acné hydratée et inférieure. Assurez-vous que l’eau potable de votre à intervalles répétés chaque jour. Il est recommandé que toutes les boissons l’arrosage d’au moins 4 à 6 GL Ser un jour de l’eau. La peau pores obstrués sont k peut et zus supplémentaires poussées d’acné k peut prendre place.Try utilisant des produits naturels de soins de la peau, où k vous pouvez vous débarrasser de l’acné ancienne. Un certain nombre d’options qui sont vendus aujourd’hui contiennent des produits chimiques qui fonctionnent vraiment dangereux pour votre affecté son k peuvent être et sont seulement des problèmes aggraver votre acné. Si vous affecté le légume le supprimer, essentiellement à mettre votre signature vous pour handicapés pores de robe de mariée pas cher peau et l’acné. produits habituels contiennent des éléments ayant des propriétés antibactériennes, votre peau pour soutenir healing.Your la vie sociale, l’acné peut souffrir à cause de robe de mariee pas cher détresse. L’acné peut être marquages différents sur la peau ainsi que votre psyché, ce qui ne sera pas facilement disparatre. Après avoir acquis les connaissances à propos de cet article acné, k être préparé en conséquence tonnes pour traiter votre acné.
    Veuillez visiter le site: http://www.whatabeautifullife.com/fr/

  • Kolfe

    The ministry of health gets tons of foreign aid in the health sector but the top officials are not using it properly. Most of the supplies given to big hospitals and medical schools via donation are looted. The system in Ethiopia is corrupted. There are no keen and devoted officials who are honest enough to building a prosperous generation. Unless those greedy thugs are out of the network, the country continues suffering from all kinds of problems. The young generation is bright, peace seeking, optimist, and eager to leading the country in positive direction. There are well qualified Ethiopians abroad who could contribute a lot to their country,however the government does not have favourable working environment. Some particular cliques are predominantly controlling every sector. Most professionals are sick and tired of all sort of bureaucracy hence they leave their country for good. The government has to have  propitious conditions for professionals.

  • http://www.facebook.com/steinbach.alan Alan Steinbach

    I am still hopeful that Ethiopia will adopt a system of medical curriculum that wil be based on principles of inquiry, where those medical professionals who want to help the country take a jump foward will be supported by the international community with adequate resources to literally jump over the barriers of insufficient instructors and utilize cloud based resources and methods of group process..sometimes called Problem Based Learning. Ethiopia has many intellectual and cultural resources that are overlooked or not well used in the present classical European based system of medical education.

  • http://www.facebook.com/gad.sharief Gad Sharief

    Hi guys. Health in Sudan had received a big blow 20 years ago by Government decisions to change the system of higher education as well as health. They called it  ”revolution of higher education”.they decided to open a university in every region without any proper studies , research or needs assessments. Suddenly and in a short period of time  the 3 national known universities became 26 , each has a medical school .Along side those some politically alliant figures opened private medical school. Most of these schools were under resourced and under financed. So they have to rely on tuition fees which was not there before the Islamist took over power.Obviously poor people were singled out
    Along side that the government privatized health services and ignored previous government run hospitals and services.Their new changes had stopped a successfull experience of one of the old universities that adopted problem  based learning  mentioned above by ALan
    The number graduated doctors jumped in few years time  from around 200/ year to a couple of thousands/year. Suddenly the job market was flooded with poorly trained doctors,who had to compete for few training jobs in the capital mostly accessible to those who have connections to the influential government officials;The majority seek marginal no medical jobs like driving cars to survive. Leaving the country is also restricted by many laws and bound to showing proof that you have completed compulsory military service.

    Now the whole situation is in chaos. looking back I could say that the government has systematically destroyed an efficient system of education as well as health replacing it with NOTHING.

    I could see a lot of similarities between Ethiopia and Sudan.
    The right path to address health problems  in my opinion is by  focusing on local health problems , invest on paramedics rather than mass production of doctors. Also take the focus away from centralized highly expensive ,highly specialized multiple story hospitals to the e to Primary care  levels  in villages and rural areas.