In Kenya, Violent Elephant Poaching Increases at an Alarming Rate

Kenya Wildlife Service officials display recovered elephants tusks and illegally held firearms. (Photo: REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya)

Kenya Wildlife Service officials display recovered elephants tusks and illegally held firearms. (Photo: REUTERS/Thomas Mukoya)

Authorities in China have reported a sharp increase in the amount of illegal ivory shipments they intercept.

Just Monday, there was news of the latest massacre of 11 elephants — killed by poachers for their ivory tusks in Kenya.

Jeffrey Gettleman covers the illicit ivory trade for The New York Times, in Nairobi, Kenya.

He said that as a pound of ivory can fetch upwards of $1,000 in Beijing, there is little chance this violent and illegal trade will slow down anytime soon in Central Africa.

To make matters worse, Gettleman said it’s almost impossible to catch the poachers.

Read the Transcript
The text below is a phonetic transcript of a radio story broadcast by PRI’s THE WORLD. It has been created on deadline by a contractor for PRI. The transcript is included here to facilitate internet searches for audio content. Please report any transcribing errors to theworld@pri.org. This transcript may not be in its final form, and it may be updated. Please be aware that the authoritative record of material distributed by PRI’s THE WORLD is the program audio.

Marco Werman: Rising demand from China and elsewhere in Asia drives lots of industries these days, even illegal ones like ivory smuggling. Authorities in China have reported a sharp increase in the amount of illegal ivory shipments they intercept. And of course just yesterday there was news of the latest massacre of elephants, killed by poachers for their ivory tusks in Kenya. Jeffrey Gettleman covers the illicit ivory trade for The New York Times. He’s in Nairobi. Jeff, you wrote that this was one of the worst episodes of poaching in Kenya. Tell us what exactly happened.

Jeffrey Gettleman: Eleven elephants, who all were in one same family, were shot dead by poachers and had their ivory hacked out in one of the more scenic and visited parks in the country, Tsavo East National Park. And what really scared people is that that level of poaching could wipe out an entire, you know, 11 elephants in one fell swoop, is reminiscent of what was happening in Kenya in the 1980s when poaching was completely out of control, and half the elephants in Africa–went from like 1.2 million to 600,000 elephants in a span of ten years until the poaching was brought under control. And a lot of people are worried that we’re heading into a similar situation now.

Werman: What are the numbers today on poaching?

Gettleman: So it’s really hard to figure out exactly what’s happening out there, because elephants live deep in the forests and savannahs. Often they’re killed by poachers and nobody ever finds the carcasses. They decompose, they’re ripped apart by scavengers like hyenas and vultures. So sometimes you don’t know exactly how many elephants are getting killed. But that said, the best estimates indicate that there are tens of thousands of elephants being poached every year across Africa, somewhere between ten, twenty, thirty thousand, maybe more, and that is a higher number than any time since the mid-to-late 1980s.

Werman: Wow. What is the population approximately of elephants in Kenya?

Gettleman: I think it’s around 50,000, forty to fifty thousand, and in Africa, the total continent, there was 1.2 million in 1980. In 1990 there was 600,000.

Werman: I’m just curious, how do events like this affect Kenyans?

Gettleman: They get really upset, because Kenya derives a lot of income and pride and identity from its wildlife. Tourism is one of the biggest industries in Kenya. It generates over a billion dollars per year and something like five or six hundred thousand jobs. So it’s really scary to Kenyans to have their wildlife being wiped out, especially when the demand for the ivory is 8,000 miles away in China.

Werman: I mean, given how lucrative ivory is, if you look just at the case of Kenya, is it time for the Kenyan government to think about a full-scale military operation to protect the elephants, and not just park ranger protection?

Gettleman: You know, they sometimes call on the military to help out in some of these African countries, but like in Congo, they use the military to fight poachers. It’s just the distances are too vast. And it’s like the war on drugs. I mean, think of how much money the American government and others spend on trying to intercept drug shipments and to patrol the skies, and the seas, and the borders. You know, billions of dollars and lots of resources and the drugs are still hitting the streets in the United States. So the idea is, no matter how much you beef up law enforcement, that’s not going to stop it if there’s just this insatiable demand. And so the efforts a lot of the wildlife groups are trying to do right now is trying to convince people in China that buying ivory is bad. It doesn’t just result in the death of elephants, it results in the death of people, and they’re trying to change the culture. And to me what’s interesting, and I haven’t been to China, but what’s interesting is these countries are getting increasingly modern and sophisticated, yet they still adhere to these traditional values and beliefs. Vietnam’s economy is booming, but people there still believe rhino horn powder can cure cancer, and there’s absolutely no scientific proof of that. So things like these beliefs are so deeply seated that it’s going to be very difficult to reverse them. But everybody I talk to say that’s the answer and that’s the only answer.

Werman: The New York Times’ Jeff Gettleman speaking with us from Nairobi. Much obliged, Jeff. Thank you.

Gettleman: Glad to help.

Copyright ©2012 PRI’s THE WORLD. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to PRI’s THE WORLD. This transcript may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without prior written permission. For further information, please email The World’s Permissions Coordinator at theworld@pri.org.

Discussion

3 comments for “In Kenya, Violent Elephant Poaching Increases at an Alarming Rate”

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=116508519 Sharon Kahara

    I listened to this story with deep sadness.  I’m a Kenyan Wildlife Ecologist working in California.  Gettleman was right that Kenyans feel a strong sense of pride when it comes to their wildlife.  I’ve read many angry posts on Facebook concerning the latest poaching incidents – Kenyans reactions have been that of outrage and I share that.  

    But the point at which I differ from many Kenyans is that I DO NOT believe killing poachers is the solution.  Gettleman noted that a full on war on poachers would not solve the problem.  One facebook page that goes under the name of “Kenya Wildlife Service” (Though I’m not sure if this is the official KWS FB page), asks “Would you support a ‘shoot to kill policy’ as a way of protecting our Elephants and Rhinos?” I think this was the saddest thing I’ve ever heard of in my life!! Almost everyone said yes!  (https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151343149622904&set=a.367218657903.155338.196213227903&type=1)Africa is already hair -roots deep in violence, murder, war and rape and here we are calling for more, more, more!! no wonder the world shakes its communal head at poor violent Africa.  We are perpetrating that stereotype to a tee.  Illegal Ivory and rhino horn trading will not stop just because more poor Africans were shot and killed without trial – but it MIGHT end if we work aggressively to tackle the unfounded “Chinese Medicine” claims and make it part of our global policy to put (economic?) pressure on nations that traffic Ivory and other wildlife parts.  Shame  them and then hit them where it hurts.  The problem is that as long as Africans are more than willing to shoot themselves over it, the less likely any other nation will actively get involved in pressuring China. 

    All nations are entitled to their traditional beliefs and practices, but when it is deemed harmful to humanity (e.g., female genital mutilation), or to our wildlife, then it must be stopped.  

  • http://profiles.google.com/evoldeth On Dre

    If these were white americans poaching wildlife I would have the same ‘shoot to kill policy’.  I have supported the Congo Rangers via Wildlife direct and accourding to their stories these are not simply small time criminals in the shadows but well armed syndicates.  No nation would or should allows groups like these operating in their borders.  I fail to see how targeting a few poachers would not be as effective as changing 1 billion peoples minds however, I do admit I could be wrong.  I do agree with you that a multi pronged strategy must be taken.  One comment from another board struke my interest.  Take cow hoofs and flood the market with counterfet “horns”.  I dont know…All I can do is send what litte I can to those who I hope will do the most good with it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=116508519 Sharon Kahara

    The reason I’m against a “shoot to kill” policy is not because I empathize with poachers of any color.  I’m against a tit for tat policy that is vengeful and only satisfies our immediate blood-lust.  Believe me, folks in developed countries also weighed in on the same debate and strongly advocated to shoot Africans if they got the chance.  What they don’t understand is that life is very cheap in Africa, and so such a policy though shocking in the developed world is laughable in Africa. 

    My argument is simple – shooting a few poachers today only drives prices up as the replacement poachers demand more from traffikers for their dangerous work.   The Asian dealers care very little for African lives lost and so it stands that Africans should be the first to value their own lives enough (yes poachers as well as rangers) to make this an issue of national priority.  Shooting poachers is a simplistic approach and destroys our ability to track the real villains – the traffickers. 

    There are many other ideas – even “flooding the market with fake horns” that should be taken into consideration BEFORE shooting the very people who may be our best hope for future conservation. I’m a wildlifer and I know that tracking animals even as large as elephants and rhinos is hard work.  You need to be hardy, ready to spend long hours in harsh hot/cold/ dusty conditions.  I would hire ex-poachers for wildlife work in a second if I had the money.